Guilty Witness
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Season 1, Episode 11
Episode #11

First aired: 11 December 1955

Hitchcock time: 1:31
Story time: 22:10
Total episode time: 24:54

My rating: 7/10




Director: Robert Stevens    Teleplay: Robert C. Dennis    Story: Morris Hershman    Associate producer: Joan Harrison    Director of photography: Reggie Lanning    Art director: Martin Obzina    Editorial supervisor: Richard G. Wray    Film editor: Edward W. Williams    Music supervisor: Stanley Wilson    Assistant director: Richard Birnie    Set decorator: Jerry Welch    Sound: Hugh McDowell    Wardrobe supervisor: Vincent Dee    Makeup: William Oakley   

Cast: Judith Evelyn, Kathleen Maguire, Joseph Mantell.



Plot summary:
Grocer Stanley Crane (Joe Mantell) serves one of his customers outside his store when the tenant from upstairs, Mr. Verber walks past. Crane asks about Verber's baby who has recently had colic. Verber asks Crane if the baby crying bothers him but Crane brushes it off saying that babies have to cry. When Crane goes inside his store to serve another customer, Mrs. Verber walks in with a bruise on her face and she tells him she tripped over the baby's toy. Crane's wife Dorothy (Kathleen Maguire) walks in and after seeing the bruise on Mrs. Verber's face she tells her husband she suspects the couple had a fight. Stanley tells his wife they should mind their own business, despite her concerns.
At the apartment Mrs. Verber takes a telephone call from the hallway and Stanley asks her to do something about the baby buggy which is parked in front of it after he bashes his leg on it. As the Cranes settle down for dinner they hear a loud commotion coming from upstairs. Some bangs and screams and then it suddenly goes silent.
The next day Mrs. Verber comes into the grocery and buys some candy. Nothing is said about the loud noise from last night, but she asks if Crane has anything she can use to put all of her baby's toys in. He brings over a large cardboard box for her during his lunch break. Dorothy questions Stanley on how big the box was and he indicates it was large enough for... [concealing a body]?
That evening a health department officer calls at Crane's apartment and carries out an inspection. When they are alone, the officer reveals to Stanley that he is in fact a detective following up on a lead that Mrs. Verber has allegedly killed her husband. When Mrs. Verber is seen leaving the apartment, the detective and Stanley let themselves into her room to look for evidence (not sure that would be legal?) They find the large box that Crane had delivered earlier and open it, but it only contains toys.
Next morning Stanley and Dorothy argue over breakfast when Dorothy won't stop going on about her murder theories. Later, Mrs. Verber comes into the store to buy some more candy and tells Stanley information regarding her husband's whereabouts that contradicts what he had been told earlier. Stanley calls the detective over and relays all of this to him. The two of them decide to check down in the basement to see if there is any sign of a body. Here, Stanley once again trips on the baby buggy...











Hitchcock's prologue: (46 secs)
[Hitch is messing with a noose on the end of a rope] "Oh good evening. I was er, just constructing a mobile for my living room. They tell me the foreign hand is becoming less popular these days. I like it though. I'm just old-fashionned I guess. But so much for fine art. This evening we have another in our series of plays designed especially for insomniacs. Actually, our stories don't cure you of your insomnia but they do take your mind off your problems by stimulating your imagination and give you something to think about as you lie there in the dark. Tonight's story will follow after we give this wake... ful... ness test."

Hitchcock's epilogue: (45 secs)
"Well that was a touching ending. Of course none of the story really happened; it was all made up. Just a tissue of lies out of some writer's head. For the benefit of those of you who prefer truth to fiction, we shall now present some. Here, before I return are some unadorned facts, presented honestly and candidly and with impartiality and objectivity. [fade out for commercial; fade in] You know truth may be stranger than fiction after all. But tune in again next week when we have another whopper to tell you. Good night."


My opinion:
A decent episode though with a small element of predictability to it. I did like the double-twist ending though!

! SPOILERS !
The body is found in the basement concealed in the baby's pram. Mrs. Verber confesses to the killing but then reveals she killed her husband because he was planning to run away with the grocer's wife!


Trivia:
•The grocery store is at number 2349; The Cranes live in room 102, the Verbers live in room 202.
•Pretty sure that police protocol wouldn't allow a member of the public to go into a suspect's apartment with them during a live murder case investigation?

Judith Evelyn
Amelia Verber
Kathleen Maguire
Dorothy Crane
Joseph Mantell
Stanley Crane
Robert F. Simon
Detective Halloran
Ed Kemmer
Mr. Verber
Grazia Narciso
Mrs. Silvetski
Laiola Wendorff
Mrs. Santini


CREDITS


This page was last updated on: 11 October 2026