The Case Of Mr. Pelham
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Season 1, Episode 10
Episode #10

First aired: 04 December 1955

Hitchcock time: 1:18
Story time: 21:58
Total episode time: 24:23

My rating: 6/10




Director: Alfred Hitchcock    Teleplay: Francis Cockrell    Story: Anthony Armstrong    Associate producer: Joan Harrison    Director of photography: John L. Russell, Jr.    Art director: James S. Redd    Editorial supervisor: Richard G. Wray    Film editor: Edward W. Williams    Music supervisor: Stanley Wilson    Assistant director: Jack Corrick    Set decorator: James S. Redd    Sound: William Brady    Wardrobe supervisor: Vincent Dee    Makeup: Lee Lotito, Jr.   

Cast: Tom Ewell, Raymond Bailey.



Plot summary:
Albert Pelham (Tom Ewell) is an ordinary man with an extraordinary problem. One evening whilst he is drinking at his local club he confides in a psychiatrist Dr. Harley (Raymond Bailey) about a series of incidents involving himself being mistaken by others. He recalls somebody telling him they saw him at Madison Square Garden for a boxing fight, but Pelham shrugs it off merely as a mistaken identity. Pelham then goes on to tell the doctor about another incident that happened a few days ago at the very club they are sitting in. In a flashback sequence, Pelham tries to introduce a friend of his to a client he is talking with when the friend calls Pelham out for ignoring him a couple of days previously. Pelham insists that he was in Philadelphia at the time so it couldn't have been him.
Dr. Harley suggests that doubles aren't that rare and one can only really tell the difference when both are together at the same time. Pelham then recalls another recent incident where an attendant handed him a carton of cigarettes that he had allegedly left at the club the night before. Pelham tells the attendant that it must be some kind of joke as he wasn't at the club at the time, but the attendant insists he was. The same night Pelham returns home to find his confused servant who tells him he had seen him earlier. Pelham finds an identical collar and tie of his on his desk which backs up the servant's claim. Later, Pelham has a discussion with his secretary who hands him some paperwork that he has no recollection of dictating though he accepts they are in his style.
Pelham continues to talk to Dr. Harley whilst recalling yet another incident where he had an argument with servant over why he didn't receive his supper. The servant once again reminds him that he had already eaten it and shows him evidence with the empty plate still on the table.
Pelham tells the doctor that he will change his routine and his tie so that the 'imposter' wouldn't be able to impersonate him. One day in his office Pelham sees a check he had supposedly signed for the bank and realizes it has his new signature on it. He telephones his servant but a man named 'Pelham' answers. Eventually, Pelham confronts his doppleganger at home and the two Mr. Pelham's try to convince the servant (played by Justice Watson) of their true identities.











Hitchcock's prologue: (43 secs)
"Good evening. Due to circumstances beyond our control tragedy will not strike tonight. I'm dreadfully sorry, perhaps some other time. However, I have just witnessed a sneak preview of this evening's story. I found it simply frightening. Sometimes death is not the worst that can befall a man and I don't refer to torture or any type of violence. I mean the quiet little insidious devices that can drive a man out of his mind, like putting bubble gum in someone's coat pocket. Tonight's little frolic is called 'The Case Of Mr. Pelham'.

Hitchcock's epilogue: (35 secs)
[Hitch is seen struggling with two orderlies] "But I'm Alfred Hitchcock. I am, I can prove it!"
Orderly: "Sure, sure, everybody is."
Hitch: "I am, I insist."
[the orderlies carry him away as the camera pans left to reveal the real Hitchcock]
Hitch: "An astounding hoax. He carried off the impersonation brilliantly, except for one thing: bubble-gum in his pocket, indeed. Alfred Hitchcock wouldn't be caught dead with bubble gum in his pocket." [gunshot] "Poor chap. If you'll excuse me, I need a moment to pull myself together."


My opinion:
I was a bit disappointed with the explanation/spoiler here, as I felt it was a cheap ending. The epilogue segment features two men in white coats dragging poor Hitchcock away despite his protests! Pure gold.

! SPOILERS !
Well not really a spoiler, because the explanation for the double is simply that Pelham is "mad".


Trivia:
•Re-made as the movie "The Man Who Haunted Himself" in 1970, starring Roger Moore.
•Hitchcock's opening dialogue has been trimmed for the DVD release.
•In 1956, Alfred Hitchcock was nominated for a Best Director - Film Series Primetime Emmy for this.
•Albert Pelham lives at 598 Madison Avenue. His middle initial is W. Screenshot.

Tom Ewell
Albert W. Pelham
Raymond Bailey
Dr. Harley
Justice Watson
Peterson, the butler
Kirby Smith
Tom Mason
Kay Stewart
Miss Clement, secretary
John Compton
Vincent
Jan Arvan
Harry
Norman Willis
Ray, the bartender
Tim Graham
Lawyer
Richard Collier
Tie salesman
Diane Brewster
Typist


CREDITS


This page was last updated on: 10 October 2026