The Baby Sitter
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Season 1, Episode 32
Episode #32

First aired: 06 May 1956

Hitchcock time: 0:47
Story time: 21:32
Total episode time: 23:42

My rating: 6/10




Director: Robert Stevens    Teleplay: Sarett Rudley    Story: Emily Neff    Associate producer: Joan Harrison    Director of photography: Reggie Lanning    Art director: Martin Obzina    Editorial supervisor: Richard G. Wray    Film editor: Edward W. Williams    Music supervisor: Stanley Wilson    Assistant director: Richard Birnie    Set decorator: James S. Redd    Sound: Earl Crain, Jr.    Wardrobe supervisor: Vincent Dee    Makeup: Jack Barron    Furs: Beckman - Beverly Hills   

Cast: Thelma Ritter, Mary Wickes, Carol Mathews.



Plot summary:
A police sergeant desperately attempts to furnish information from Lottie Slocom, a middle-aged woman after the murder of Mrs. Nash, whom she was working for as her baby sitter. After he fails to get her to tell him anything the sergeant leaves just as Lottie's friend Blanche Armstaedter arrives at the apartment. She brings cherry chocolate with tutti frutti and offers it to Lottie as a bribe in order to get the story from her. Lottie tells the story of how she disliked the woman and her behaviour towards her husband.
In a flashback sequence, Lottie witnesses an argument between Mr. & Mrs. Nash at their apartment when the wife refuses to accompany her husband to his boss's house for the evening. The downtrodden Mr. Nash telephones his boss to make an excuse whilst his wife laughs. Lottie confronts Mrs. Nash and gives her some strong opinions on the matter. Mr. Nash breaks up the confrontation and defends Lottie, even paying her a compliment.
Back at Lottie's apartment she confesses to Blanche that she thought a lot of Mr. Nash -
"I may be a size 14 but I could get to be a size 10 for him!"
Blanche laughs at the thought of them being together until she suddenly proposes that Lottie may have killed Mrs. Nash?
Lottie and her daughter Jane discuss how Lottie was only 98lbs when she married her father, but how easy it is to let herself go when there is no man around. After Jane pops out to the shops, Lottie receives a surprise visitor in Mr. DiMario - a man she thinks had a hand in the murder of Mrs. Nash. He warns Lottie not to open her mouth regarding the murder.
The next day Lottie comes home with some brand new clothes and an exercise rope determined to lose some weight in order to improve her chances with the now-available Mr. Nash. Blanche humours her of course until the police sergeant reappears and starts asking her questions about the murder. Clearly flustered by his interrogation of her, Lottie breaks down in tears.
Lottie decides to write Mr. Nash a letter, asking for his help as she remembers the events leading up to his wife's murder. She is at the apartment, snooping around, criticizing Mrs. Nash and her lifestyle and how undeserving she was of Mr. Nash's affections when he walks in on Lottie trying on his wife's fur coat. Shortly afterwards Mrs. Nash comes home with her boyfriend Mr. DiMario, openly kissing each other without a care in the world.
As Lottie is finishing up writing her letter to Nash, he turns up at her apartment unexpectedly...









Hitchcock's prologue: (? secs)
"Good evening. Tonight's story is called 'The Baby Sitter'. You know, I don't think taking care of a baby is any great chore at all, if you are properly prepared. I bring my comforts with me. A portable radio, a few books, a hot lunch, a cold drink, a heavy mallot and if that fails, ear-plugs. Good heavens, I forgot the baby. Stay right where you are. I'll be back."

Hitchcock's epilogue: (47 secs)
[Hitch is sitting on a bench holding a large mallet and with a baby crying in a pram next to him] "And now I suppose you babies who have just put the sitter to bed are wondering about Mr. Nash. He escaped in his automobile but not for long. He was soon arrested for failing to yield the right of way. But he wasn't exactly arrested, you see, it was a train he failed to yield to. And now children if you aren't naughty and if the rabbit doesn't get drunk drinking too much carrot tea and fall on the elephant's trunk, next week I'll tell you another story. Good night."


My opinion:
Thelma Ritter is, as always on top form as the baby sitter suspected of killing Mrs. Nash. Throughout the episode we suspect she is probably innocent but cannot be sure. There is enough suspense in this aspect to carry the episode through until its conclusion, but overall it's rather weak.

! SPOILERS !
Although it is never conclusively explained who killed Mrs. Nash - the finger of suspicion points towards Mr. Nash, especially after he physically assaults Lottie in her bedroom at the very end of the episode.


Trivia:
•The episode on the DVD omits Hitch's opening dialogue and the story begins immediately after the opening titles. However, I was able to retrieve the original scene from the Grams/Wikstrom book.
•This was Michael Ansara's third and last appearance in the series. It was also the third appearance from Ray Teal.
•The unseen baby is called Bobby.
•Lottie lives in apartment 204.

Thelma Ritter
Mrs. Lottie Slocum
Mary Wickes
Sophie Armstedder
Carol Mathews
Clara Nash
Theodore Newton
Mr. Nash
Reba Tassel
Janie
Michael Ansara
Mr. Demario
Ray Teal
Sergeant


CREDITS


This page was last updated on: 01 November 2026