The Perfect Murder
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Season 1, Episode 24
Episode #24

First aired: 11 March 1956

Hitchcock time: 1:15
Story time: 21:52
Total episode time: 24:35

My rating: -/10




Director: Robert Stevens    Teleplay: Victor Wolfson    Story: Stacey Aumonier    Producer: Joan Harrison    Director of photography: Reggie Lanning    Art director: Martin Obzina    Editorial supervisor: Richard G. Wray    Film editor: Edward W. Williams    Music supervisor: Stanley Wilson    Assistant director: Richard Birnie    Set decorator: James S. Redd    Sound: Richard Tyler    Wardrobe supervisor: Vincent Dee    Makeup: Jack Barron   

Cast: Hurd Hatfield, Mildred Natwick.



Plot summary:
At the reading of a will, two brothers Paul and Henri Tallendier (Hurd Hatfield and Philip Coolidge) find that they are to inherit some money from their dead aunt's estate, much to the chagrin of their living aunt Rosalie (Mildred Natwick), who is the main beneficiary of the inheritance. Eager to spend his money before he has received it, Paul makes a play on Rosalie's heartstrings and pretends to be ill, gaining her sympathy. After she allows him to move in with her to keep her company, the two get on just fine, though she is mindful of his interest in her dying in order for him to collect. Paul even teases her in showing how easy it would be for him to kill her if he wanted to.
Henri is just as scheming and is desperate to have money, showing up at Rosalie's house in the middle of the night to steal silver picture frames so that he can pawn them. Paul catches him and they discuss how much easier and financially better their lives would be if Aunt Rosalie was killed. The next day the brothers meet at a cafe and discuss how they are going to do it and Paul tells Henri to ground some glass into a fine powder so that they can put it into her food. However, the plan backfires spectacularly!









Hitchcock's prologue: (39 secs)
[Hitch appears with his back to the camera with a knife sticking in his back before turning around to face the camera] "Oh good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to Hollywood. I think everyone enjoys a nice murder... provided he's not the victim. Well, tonight's little comedy of bad manners is concerned with that dream of all of us who harbor homicidal tendencies. The perfect murder. Of course to be serious for a moment there is no such thing as a nice murder or a perfect murder. It is always a sordid, despicable business... especially if you don't have a good lawyer."

Hitchcock's epilogue: (36 secs)
"As for the eventual outcome of tonight's crime the case was later re-opened and Henri arrested and convicted of violating the pure food and drug act. He had used an inferior grade of glass. We shall have our next performance of another play one week from tonight. Oh yes, normally I detest sentimentality, but I must leave you with this little thought for the day: never turn your back on a friend. Good night."


My opinion:
-

! SPOILERS !
After getting her drunk, Paul puts the glass into his aunt's souffle and then goes out, expecting her to eat it and later die. Unfortunately for him, he was unaware that the aunt refused the food and opted for fish instead. But fear not, the eggs didn't go to waste - Paul ate them when he came home. Oops. This promotes Henri to being her sole heir!


Trivia:
•

Hurd Hatfield
Philip Coolidge
Mildred Natwick
Madame Aunt Rosalie
Philip Coolidge
Henri Tallendier
Gladys Hurlbut
Ernestine the cook
Walter Kingsford
Doctor
Percy Helton
Lawyer
Hope Summers
Marie
Jack Chefe
Waiter


CREDITS


This page was last updated on: 24 October 2026