The Older Sister
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Season 1, Episode 17
Episode #17

First aired: 22 January 1956

Hitchcock time: -:--
Story time: --:--
Total episode time: 24:46

My rating: 7/10




Director: Robert Stevens    Teleplay: Robert C. Dennis    Story: Lillian de La Torre    Associate producer: Joan Harrison    Director of photography: Reggie Lanning    Art director: Martin Obzina    Editorial supervisor: Richard G. Wray    Film editor: Edward W. Williams    Music supervisor: Stanley Wilson    Assistant director: Richard Birnie    Set decorator: James S. Redd    Sound: William Brady    Wardrobe supervisor: Vincent Dee    Makeup: Lee Lotito, Jr.   

Cast: Joan Lorring, Carmen Mathews, Polly Rowles.



Plot summary:
One year after the murder of a married couple, a hard-nosed reporter from the Sacramento Record, Nell Cutts (Polly Rowles), shows up at the house where the crime was committed and wastes no time in interrogating the sister of the woman accused. Nell goes over the details of how the murders were carried out whilst Emma Borden (Joan Lorring) reminds the reporter that her sister, Lizzie (Carmen Mathews) was acquitted of any wrong doing. Lizzie appears and demands the reporter leave. Lizzie retrieves the "lost" murder weapon, an axe, and explains the whole story to Emma. Unfortunately for them both, Nell returns, barges her way into the house and discovers the axe, demands a statement and uncovers the truth.











Hitchcock's prologue: (- secs)
X

Hitchcock's epilogue: (- secs)
X


My opinion:
It's an all-female cast which is not quite as suspenseful as previous episodes in the series, largely due to the fact the spoiler is given up far too early in the story. The ending was so poorly constructed, with the axe being hidden under a newspaper and the unlikelihood the reporter would just happen to want to read the paper, and the long shot of Lizzie sitting in the chair as the episode ends. Hitchcock's daughter Patricia has a small cameo at the beginning as the maid who leaves the house.

! SPOILERS !
Emma Borden is a good liar. She is also a complete crackpot. She was behind the murders but her sister Lizzie was the one who covered for her, despite knowing that Emma was guilty. Though the ending does make one think maybe Lizzie was guilty all along?


Trivia:
•Based on the 1947 one-act play, "Good-Bye, Miss Lizzie Borden" by Lillian de la Torre.

Joan Lorring
Miss Emma Borden
Carmen Mathews
Miss Lizzie Borden
Polly Rowles
Nell Cutts, the reporter
Patricia Hitchcock
Margaret, the maid
Wendy Winkleman
Little singing girl
Kay Stewart
Woman on the street


CREDITS


This page was last updated on: 17 October 2026